Shop March 4, 2024

Try Before You Buy: The perfect black pump

ABC News Photo Illustration
Try Before You Buy: Heels from Cole Haan, Naturalizer and Kelly & Katie

The perfect black pump can elevate any look, but which brand should you choose when shopping?

We looked at several options including the three below to see if their height, construction and overall looks are up to par when it comes to style and comfort.

Editor's Picks

Take the Naturalizer heels you see below for example: A non-slip outsole, cushioning in the sole, arch and heel support, and more all make for more comfortable wear, while the sleek, timeless silhouette will look chic for years to come.

MORE: Spring 2024 fashion forecast: Insights from top experts on must-have trends to shop

Cole Haan's Grand Ambition pumps are similarly versatile and offer a "supportive, anatomically molded footbed" in addition to extra padding throughout, proving you don't have to sacrifice style for comfort when it comes to cute shoes.

Offering a fresh take on the classic, the Kelly & Katie pumps are constructed from suede and leather and have a unique, architectural heel that's eye-catching and offers a bit more support thanks to its width.

Keep scrolling to shop your perfect black pump below!

Get more shopGMA! Sign up for our newsletter, and follow on Instagram and TikTok.

By clicking on these shopping links, visitors will leave Goodmorningamerica.com. These e-commerce sites are operated under different terms and privacy policies than Goodmorningamerica.com. ABC will receive a commission for purchases made through these links. Prices may change from the date of publication.

Kelly & Katie Juleii Pump

Price: $49.99 · 37% Savings
From DSW

Original: $80

Women's Grand Ambition Pumps

Price: $180 · From Cole Haan

Anna Pump

Price: $130 · From Naturalizer