Shop January 21, 2019

How to pick the right shoe for your workout

Peloton
Rebecca Kennedy, master tread instructor at Peloton, teaches a treadmill class at Peloton's New York City studio.

Welcome to GMA’s New Year, Best You. As we ring in 2019, we are sharing everything you need to start the new year strong. From keeping your New Year's resolutions going to Instagram-worthy meal prep to workout programs to eating plans to taking time for yourself, we have it all covered.

Starting 2019 on the right foot can quickly lead to foot pain if the shoes you're working out in are not right.

Whether you are running, cross-training or weight lifting, comfort is key, according to Stephanie Blozy, the owner of a Fleet Feet Sports store in West Hartford, Connecticut.

"If the shoe feels comfortable on your foot, it’s probably going to be less likely to cause injury down the road," she said.

(MORE: Serena Williams says her Australian Open green jumpsuit is celebrating moms 'that are trying to get back and get fit')

Rebecca Kennedy, master tread instructor at Peloton, which launched its at-home tread workouts last year, said women need to be savvy shoe shoppers to feel and look their best.

"The shoe is the barrier between your foot and whatever surface you’re on, so it has the potential to do a lot of good or be detrimental," she said. "If you choose something that’s not right for your foot or the way you move, then you’re going to be susceptible to injury."

(MORE: Start your 2019 detox with these 9 charcoal products)

Here are eight tips from Kennedy and Blozy on finding the perfect shoe, followed by their picks for the best sneakers for different workouts.

1. Try on more than one shoe so you know what you like and don't like.

2. Buy workout shoes in a half size bigger than your everyday shoe, like a heel, because your feet will swell and expand during exercise.

3. When you find a shoe that fits, try it in a half size bigger and a half size smaller to make sure you have the right size.

4. Don't be swayed by color or price. Go for the shoe that is comfortable, not the one that is best looking. Expect to pay around $120 for a great running shoe.

5. Go to a store that will fit you for a shoe instead of trying to sell you one. "There are plenty of running stores that will get you up on a tread and film your gate and put you in several different brands and sizes and widths to determine what is best," said Kennedy.

6. Buy more than one pair of sneakers, ideally from different brands, so you can rotate them, giving the shoes time to dry after workouts and your feet a chance to use different muscles.

7. Pick a shoe based on your activity, so if you run more than two miles in a workout, you should be in a running shoe. If you are doing a HIIT and strength class, like OrangeTheory, wear a cross-training shoe that is closer to the ground and has more flexibility.

8. Replace your running shoes at least every 300 to 500 miles. "I like to just turn [my shoes] over and see where the wear and tear is, how much of the cushion has gone away, does it seem like I’m running on pavement," Kennedy said.

"Good Morning America" has affiliate partnerships, so we will get a small share of revenue from your purchases through these links. All product prices are determined by the retailer and subject to change. By visiting these websites, you will leave GoodMorningAmerica.com and any information you share with the retailer will be governed by its website's terms and conditions and privacy policies.

Best shoes for running on a treadmill

Brooks Launch 6

Price: $100

Saucony Kinvara

Price: $110

Nike Air Zoom Pegasus 35

Price: $120

Best shoes for outdoor running

KARHU Ikoni

Price: $130

adidas Running UltraBOOST All Terrain

Price: $179.99

Brooks Adrenaline GTS 19

Price: $130

Best shoes for cross-training

NIKE Metcon DSX Flyknit 2 Training Shoe

Price: $89.98 + Free Shipping! · 40% Savings

Original: $150

New Balance Fresh Foam Zante Trainer

Price: $89.95

Best shoes for weightlifting

Reebok Legacy Lifter

Price: $186

Nike Romaleos 3

Price: $159.97 · 20% Savings

Original: $200